Collective vs NewSelf
In our scoring, Collective edges ahead overall (8.3 vs 8.2 out of 10).
WeightLossRankings.org is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. How we make money
Key differences
- Price
- Collective $59/mo plus a separate membership; NewSelf $100/mo on a 3-month prepaid plan (compounded semaglutide · not like-for-like, so neither is marked cheaper)
- Coverage
- Collective 44 states; NewSelf 48 states + PR (only NewSelf: Alabama, California, Massachusetts and 2 more)
- Included
- Collective: medication, clinician visits, shipping; NewSelf: medication, clinician visits, shipping
- Safety
- FDA warning letters on record: Collective none, NewSelf 1

Collective
Affiliate partnerBest for the lowest flat medication price if you can absorb an annual membership fee
semaglutide
$59
+ separate membership
Our score 8.3/10

NewSelf
Best for lowest-cost compounded GLP-1 at one price for every dose, if a 3-month commitment works for you
semaglutide
$100
on a 3-month prepaid plan
Our score 8.2/10
We may earn a commission if you sign up through these links. Partner status can affect which provider we feature; it never changes a score or a price.
Costs & coverage
Published prices with their terms attached. Yearly figures are modeled from the standing price and billing cadence. A check mark marks the better side, on like-for-like rows only.
Collective
NewSelf
Price
Semaglutide / month
$59/mo
+ separate membership
$100/mo
on a 3-month prepaid plan
Semaglutide / year (modeled)
$708
excludes the membership
$1,200
Tirzepatide / month
$69/mo
+ separate membership
$144/mo
on a 3-month prepaid plan
Tirzepatide / year (modeled)
$828
excludes the membership
$1,728
Separate membership required
Yes, not in the listed price
Not stated
Coverage
State availability
44 states
48 states + PR
Included in the price
Medication, clinician visits, shipping
Medication, clinician visits, shipping
Terms & safety
Price shown
Before intake
Before intake
Cancel anytime
Better on this row: Yes
No
Minimum commitment
Medication is month-to-month; the membership is billed annually
3-month plan for the listed price
Refunds
'All membership fees are non-refundable, and partial-period refunds are not provided.'
No refunds after the doctor visit; full refund if the doctor declines; $99 fee if you cancel before the visit
Early-cancellation fee
Better on this row: None
Yes
FDA warning letters
Better on this row: None on record
1 warning letter
Provider facts checked
October 2026
October 2026
Show where they differ by stateHide state lists
Only NewSelf (4 states + PR)
- Alabama
- California
- Massachusetts
- PR
- Washington
Every dose and plan: Collective · NewSelf
Get alerted when GLP-1 prices drop
Join the GLP-1 price-watch list — we re-verify 540+ providers' prices on their own sites and email you when tracked prices move.
Which fits your priorities?
Only the points where these two differ, from the table above and each provider’s record.

Choose Collective if…
- Cancel anytime; No early-cancellation fee
- No FDA warning letters on record (NewSelf has 1)
- Flat pricing at every dose, so titrating up does not raise the bill
What to weigh up
- Listed compounded semaglutide price excludes a required membership
- Not available in 4 states + PR that NewSelf serves

Choose NewSelf if…
- Serves 4 states + PR that Collective doesn't
- Same price at every dose, so your bill doesn't rise as you titrate up
- No membership fee; the visit, medication and shipping are bundled
What to weigh up
- 1 FDA warning letter on record
- Its $100/mo compounded semaglutide price needs a 3-month prepaid plan
Collective and NewSelf in context
A membership fee sits between these two prices for compounded semaglutide: one figure excludes a required membership. Until that fee is added in, Collective and NewSelf cannot be ranked on cost. Our no-membership GLP-1 list collects the programs whose price already includes everything. On score, Collective is at 8.3 and NewSelf at 8.2 out of 10.
Both keep one price at every dose, so the month-one figure is also the month-six figure. Other programs that price this way are on our flat-price GLP-1 list. Coverage differs too: NewSelf lists 4 states that Collective does not, including Alabama and California. NewSelf has 1 FDA warning letter on file and Collective has none; the letters are in our FDA warning letter database.
The next head-to-head for Collective is Collective vs Oak; Oak sells semaglutide and tirzepatide and lists 48 states. For NewSelf, it is NewSelf vs CoreAge Rx; CoreAge Rx sells semaglutide and tirzepatide and lists 50 states. If neither fits, the wider shortlists are alternatives to Collective and alternatives to NewSelf.
Explore the scoring factors
Both providers are scored on the same six-dimension framework. The gradient bar marks the stronger side on each dimension.
Collective
8.3/10
NewSelf
8.2/10
Value25%
Effectiveness25%
User Experience15%
Trust & Safety15%
Accessibility10%
Support10%
Ready to start? Vetted GLP-1 providers
Vetted telehealth providers that prescribe GLP-1 online.
No insurance needed · vetted by our editors
WeightLossRankings.org is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. How we make money
Ro
FDA-approved brand GLP-1s, including the Wegovy pill and Foundayo, with insurance help
Read full review →From $149/mo (+ required membership)
Get started →Collective
The lowest flat medication price if you can absorb an annual membership fee
Read full review →From $59/mo (+ required membership)
Get started →CoreAge Rx
Lowest-price compounded semaglutide and tirzepatide with one flat price at every dose
Read full review →From $79/mo (“starting at” price)
Get started →Collective vs NewSelf: FAQ
Key terms, explained
New to GLP-1s? Tap any term for a quick, plain-English definition.
- Semaglutide · Drugs and brands
- Tirzepatide · Drugs and brands
- Compounded GLP-1 · Pharmacy and drug forms
- 503A pharmacy · Pharmacy and drug forms
- PCAB accreditation · Pharmacy and drug forms
- Prior authorization (PA) · Insurance and regulatory
- Off-label use · Insurance and regulatory
- FDA Drug Shortage List · Insurance and regulatory
Related comparisons
Continue exploring Collective and NewSelf head-to-heads in the same category.
- Collective vs Amazon One Medical
- Collective vs Vytora Health
- Collective vs CoreAge Rx
- NewSelf vs Amazon One Medical
- NewSelf vs Vytora Health
- NewSelf vs CoreAge Rx
Or see the full category ranking, or alternatives to Collective and NewSelf.
Wegovy®, Ozempic®, and Rybelsus® are trademarks of Novo Nordisk A/S. Mounjaro® and Zepbound® are trademarks of Eli Lilly and Company. All other product names and trademarks referenced on this page belong to their respective owners. WeightLossRankings.org is not affiliated with any pharmaceutical manufacturer. See trademark disclaimer.